Best Catcher's Equipment: Complete Guide to Gear Behind the Plate
Catching is arguably the most equipment-intensive position in baseball. From masks that can withstand 90+ mph foul tips to chest protectors that absorb the impact of wild pitches, catchers rely on specialized gear not just for peak performance but for essential safety. In this comprehensive guide, we'll break down everything you need to know about selecting the best catcher's equipment for players at every level, from youth leagues to college and beyond.
The Essential Catcher's Gear Checklist
Before diving into specific recommendations, here's what every catcher needs in their equipment bag:
- Catcher's mask/helmet
- Chest protector
- Leg guards
- Catcher's mitt
- Protective cup (mandatory)
- Throat guard
- Knee savers (optional but recommended)
- Catcher's bag
Now let's examine each category in detail with specific recommendations for different age groups and skill levels.
Photo by form PxHere
Catcher's Masks and Helmets
The catcher's mask is your first line of defense against foul tips, errant swings, and wild pitches. There are two main styles to consider:
Hockey-Style Masks vs. Traditional Two-Piece Systems
Hockey-style masks combine the helmet and face protection in one unit, offering superior protection and comfort for most catchers. They've become increasingly popular at all levels of play.
Traditional two-piece systems feature a separate skull cap and mask, offering better ventilation but slightly less protection than hockey-style options.
Best Hockey-Style Masks
1. All-Star System 7 MVP2500 Helmet
Why we recommend it: This premium helmet combines professional-grade protection with exceptional comfort and airflow, making it the gold standard for serious catchers.
Key features:
- I-Bar Vision steel cage for maximum visibility
- MATTE finish helps reduce glare
- Impact-absorbing D30® foam liner
- Moisture-wicking antibacterial padding
- Multiple size and color options
Best for: High school, college, and advanced youth catchers
2. Easton Elite X Helmet
Why we recommend it: This mid-range option offers excellent protection at a more accessible price point without compromising on essential safety features.
Key features:
- ABS plastic shell with strategically placed ventilation
- Steel cage with optimal sight lines
- Moisture-wicking BioDri liner
- Meets NOCSAE standards at all levels
Best for: Developing youth and high school catchers
3. Mizuno Samurai Youth Helmet
Why we recommend it: Specifically designed for younger players, this helmet offers excellent protection while being lighter and more comfortable for smaller catchers.
Key features:
- Strategic ventilation system
- DryLite liner wicks away sweat
- Extended jawline protection
- Adjustable back plate for growing players
Best for: Youth catchers ages 8-14
4. Rawlings Renegade 2.0
Key features:
- DESIGNED FOR ATHLETES AGES 15 & UP
- UPGRADED RENEGADE 2.0 SHELL features moisture-wicking liner
- HIGH-STRENGTH, INCREASED IMPACT RESISTANCE CAGE offers greater protection for catchers behind the plate
- UPGRADED CHIN PAD offers improved, form-fitting comfort
- CERTIFICATION: Meets NOCSAE Standard
Best for: Available in Junior & Senior sizes
Best Traditional Masks
1. Champion Sports Umpire/Catcher's Mask
Key features:
- Reinforced steel cage, hollow wire construction
- Adjustable harness for secure fit on any size head
- Forehead, ear and throat guards add extra protection at vulnerable areas
- Durable and ultra lightweight - Weighs only 18 oz
- PREMIUM Black Leather, Tan DryTek EverClean sweat wicking pads
Best for: Adult catchers who prefer traditional systems
2. All-Star S7 Tradional Mask/Hollow Steel/Mesh Pads
Key features:
- Top quality baseball and softball catching equipment
- Protective and comfortable
- Fitted and streamlined design
Best for: Adult catchers who prefer traditional systems
3. Wilson C1K Catcher's Gear Kit (with mask)
Why we recommend it: This value-oriented traditional mask features quality construction at an accessible price point.
Key features:
- Kit includes: Catcher's Helmet, Chest Protector and Leg Guards
- Helmet (meets NOCSAE protection standard): Glossy finish; Removable moisture wicking chin pad; Adjustable straps for custom fit; Size: 7 1/8 - 7 1/2
- Chest Protector (meets NOCSAE protection standard): High-density foam padding for ultimate comfort and protection; Removable shoulder caps for increased mobility
- Leg Guards: Inner knee pad protects knees, removable for washing; Overlapping thigh pieces for maximum protection; lightweight premium grade ABS plastic; adjustable metal buckles for easy on/off and snug fit; size: 15. 5"
Best for:Recommended for ages 15+
Important note: All youth and high school leagues now require a throat guard attachment on traditional masks. These inexpensive ($10-15) accessories attach to the bottom of the mask for added protection.
Chest Protectors
A quality chest protector absorbs the impact of wild pitches and foul tips while allowing the mobility catchers need for quick movements.
Size Matters
Chest protectors are sized by length (measured from collar to waist):
- Adult: 16.5"-17" (ages 15+)
- Intermediate: 15"-16" (ages 12-15)
- Youth: 14"-15" (ages 9-12)
- Small youth: 12"-13" (ages 7-9)
Best Overall Chest Protectors
1. All-Star System 7 Axis Pro Chest Protector
Why we recommend it: This professional-grade chest protector offers unparalleled protection, comfort, and mobility with innovative technology that keeps catchers agile behind the plate.
Key features:
- S7 AXIS technology provides superior ball rebound control
- Dynamic DeltaFlex harness system moves with the catcher
- Wedge-shaped ab design for comfortable crouching
- Multiple adjustment points for custom fit
Best for: Advanced high school, college, and serious travel ball catchers
2. Easton Pro X Chest Protector
Why we recommend it: This mid-range option offers professional features at a more accessible price point, making it perfect for developing catchers.
Key features:
- NOCSAE standard certified for stacked pitches
- Memory foam construction that molds to player's body
- Reinforced shoulder caps
- Breathable quad-layer design
Best for: Competitive youth and high school catchers
3. EvoShield Pro-Srz Catcher's Chest Protector
Key features:
- Moldable Abdominal Wire: The moldable wire helps you attain a secure, contoured fit that stays in place as you move.
- Fidlock Buckle: A magnetic Fidlock buckle makes for easy on/off so you're ready to play in no time.
- SEI Certified Product: Built-in/removable pocket houses NOCSAE Chest Guard (Guard & Pocket included with Chest Protector); guard is certified by SEI to meet the NOCSAE standard
- NOCSAE: Chest guard MUST be worn in the EvoShield Pro-SRZ Catcher's Chest Protector to adhere to NOCSAE standards and regulations
Pro tip: With recent NOCSAE certification requirements for chest protectors that protect against commotio cordis (a rare but deadly condition caused by impact to the chest), make sure any chest protector you purchase meets the latest safety standards if used in organized play.
Leg Guards
Catcher's leg guards protect from foul tips, collision impacts, and the general wear of repeatedly dropping to block pitches.
Getting the Right Size
Leg guards are measured by length from knee to ankle:
- Adult: 16.5"-17" (ages 15+)
- Intermediate: 15"-16" (ages 12-15)
- Youth: 14"-15" (ages 9-12)
- Small youth: 12"-13" (ages 7-9)
Best Overall Leg Guards
1. All-Star System 7 Axis Pro Leg Guards
Why we recommend it: These premium leg guards provide exceptional protection with a lightweight design that won't restrict movement behind the plate.
Key features:
- Triple knee construction with ergonomic knee cup design
- LINQ hinge system for natural range of motion
- Removable toe extension
- Quick-adjust strapping system
Best for: Advanced high school, college, and elite youth catchers
2. Mizuno Samurai Leg Guards
Why we recommend it: These durable leg guards offer excellent balance between protection, mobility, and value.
Key features:
- K-Pad knee design for improved durability
- Triple knee caps with ergonomic design
- Strategic venting for temperature regulation
- Comfortable inner lining
Best for: Competitive youth and high school catchers
3. Easton Gametime X Leg Guards
Why we recommend it: These budget-friendly leg guards still offer quality protection and comfort for developing catchers.
Key features:
- Double knee construction
- Strategic venting system
- Inner padding with moisture-wicking properties
- Quick-adjust straps
Best for: Recreational and youth league catchers
Catcher's Mitts
Unlike standard baseball gloves, catcher's mitts are measured by circumference rather than length. The additional padding and unique design help catchers handle high-velocity pitches.
Size Guidelines
- Adult: 32"-34.5" (high school through professional)
- Youth: 30"-32" (ages 10-14)
- Small youth: 29"-30" (ages 7-10)
Best Premium Catcher's Mitts
1. Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROCM33 (33")
Why we recommend it: This professional-grade mitt offers exceptional quality leather, perfect pocket formation, and durability that will last multiple seasons with proper care.
Key features:
- Heart of the Hide leather selected for top 5% quality
- One-piece closed web design
- Deer-tanned cowhide lining
- Padded thumb and finger stalls
Best for: Serious high school, college, and elite travel ball catchers
2. Wilson A2000 SuperSkin 1790 (34")
Why we recommend it: The A2000 series offers professional quality with SuperSkin backing that reduces weight while maintaining durability.
Key features:
- Pro Stock leather selected for consistent feel
- SuperSkin backing reduces weight by 30%
- Double palm construction
- Half-moon web design
Best for: Advanced catchers who value lightweight performance
Best Mid-Range Catcher's Mitts
1. Mizuno GPS-20 Pro Select (33.5")
Why we recommend it: This mitt offers near-professional quality at a more accessible price point, making it ideal for serious developing catchers.
Key features:
- Professional Patterns: Glove patterns created for the best players in the world.
- Professional Level Lace: Same durable lace that's offered in our professional-level gloves.
- Thumb slot : Provides additional comfort and a solid, secure fit.
- 3D Silicone Logo
- Mizuno branded woven label
Best for: Competitive high school and travel ball catchers
2. All-Star Pro Elite CM3000BT (33.5")
Why we recommend it: This premium-quality mitt features Japanese tanned leather and superior construction at a mid-tier price point.
Key features:
- Japanese tanned Pro-Grade leather
- Extra-wide pocket design
- Premium rawhide lacing
- Moldable padding system
Best for: Travel ball and competitive youth catchers
Best Youth Catcher's Mitts
1. All-Star Pro-Elite CM3000BTJR Youth Catchers Mitt (31.5")
Why we recommend it: This affordable mitt offers the perfect balance of quality and value for developing youth catchers.
Key features:
- Top quality baseball and softball catching equipment
- Protective and comfortable
- Fitted and streamlined design
Best for: Youth catchers ages 10-13
2. Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher's Mitt (32.5")
Why we recommend it: Specifically designed for youth players, this mitt helps develop proper catching technique with features that make catching easier.
Key features:
- Professional Level Lace: Same Durable Lace That'S Offered In Our Professional-Level Gloves.
- Outlined, Embroidered Logo: For A Rich, Premium Look.
- Bio Soft Leather: Professional style smooth leather that has the perfect balance of oil and softness for exceptional feel and firm control that serious players demand.
Best for: Youth catchers ages 8-12
Pro tip for breaking in catcher's mitts: Unlike regular fielding gloves, catcher's mitts require more extensive break-in. Use glove oil sparingly, catch heavy balls repeatedly, and use mallets to shape the pocket for optimal performance.
Essential Accessories for Catchers
Knee Savers
These foam wedges attach to leg guards and reduce strain during extended catching sessions.
Recommended option: All-Star DeltaFlex Knee Savers ($25-35)
Throat Guards
These plastic extensions attach to masks for added protection against rising pitches and foul tips.
Recommended option: Wilson Throat Guard ($12-18)
Protective Cups
Absolutely essential for all catchers. Look for models specifically designed for the impacts catchers face.
Recommended option: Diamond MMA Athletic Cup ($40-50) or Shock Doctor Ultra Carbon Flex Cup ($30-40)
Catcher's Bags
Specialized equipment bags designed to organize and transport bulky catching gear.
Recommended options:
- No Errors NO E2 Catchers Bag - Premium option with incredible organization
- Easton E610CBP Catcher's Bag - Excellent mid-range option
- Louisville Slugger Series 5 Rig Bag - Budget-friendly but functional
Complete Catcher's Sets: Are They Worth It?
Many manufacturers offer complete sets that include mask, chest protector, and leg guards. Here's our analysis:
Best Complete Catcher's Sets:
1. All-Star System 7 Axis Three-Piece Set
Why we recommend it: This premium set offers professional-grade protection with perfectly matched components designed to work together.
Key features:
- Top-tier materials throughout
- Perfectly integrated components
- Available in multiple colors
- NOCSAE certified at all levels
Youth: Ages 9-12 | Adult: Serious high school and college catchers
2. Easton Gametime 2.0 Catcher's Set
Why we recommend it: This mid-range set offers excellent protection and value for developing catchers.
Key features:
- Consistent design across all pieces
- NOCSAE certified
- Good balance of protection and mobility
- Available in multiple colors
Best for: Youth-Adult
3. Mizuno Samurai Youth Set
Why we recommend it: This youth-specific set offers excellent protection with sizing and features appropriate for younger players.
Key features:
- Components designed specifically for youth bodies
- Simplified adjustment systems
- Durable construction for growing players
- Multiple color options
Best for: Youth league catchers ages 8-12
Build Your Own vs. Complete Sets
When to buy a complete set:
- Youth players just starting out
- Players on a budget who need all components
- When consistent appearance/color is important
When to piece together individual items:
- When you need to replace just one component
- For players with non-standard body proportions
- When seeking absolute top-of-line performance in each category
How Much Should You Spend on Catcher's Gear?
The right investment depends on the player's commitment level, age, and competition level:
- Youth Recreational Level: $150-250 for complete setup
- Competitive Youth/Travel Ball: $300-500 for quality essential gear
- High School/College Level: $600-900 for premium gear that offers maximum protection
- Professional Aspirations: $900+ for top-tier protection and performance
Remember that catcher's equipment is primarily about safety. While budget considerations are valid, never compromise on protective quality, especially for the mask and chest protector.
Care and Maintenance for Catcher's Equipment
To maximize the lifespan of your investment:
- Air dry all gear after each use to prevent odor and material breakdown
- Wipe down plastic components with mild disinfectant regularly
- Use leather conditioner on your mitt every few weeks during season
- Tighten screws and check straps before each game
- Store in a well-ventilated catcher's bag away from extreme temperatures
Selecting Gear for Specific Scenarios
Youth Catchers (Ages 8-12)
Focus on:
- Proper fit (avoid "room to grow" purchases for safety gear)
- Lightweight materials that won't tire young players
- Simplified adjustment systems
- Durability to withstand learning process
Fast-Pitch Softball Catchers
Look for:
- Enhanced throat protection for rising pitches
- Chest protectors with upper chest/collarbone padding
- Leg guards with extended shin coverage
- Mitts with deeper pockets for larger softball
Cold Weather Catching
Consider:
- Moisture-wicking base layers under gear
- Neoprene sleeve for throwing arm
- Fingerless gloves under mitt for extreme conditions
- Higher-quality mask padding that won't harden in cold temperatures
Final Thoughts
Quality catcher's equipment is an investment in both performance and safety. While premium gear comes with higher price tags, the protection, comfort, and durability typically justify the additional cost for committed catchers. Focus first on proper fit and safety certifications before considering aesthetic elements like color and style.
For youth players just exploring the position, starter sets offer good value while they determine their interest level. For dedicated catchers, gradually upgrading to position-specific premium gear will enhance both safety and performance behind the plate.
Remember that even the best gear requires proper technique. Invest not just in quality equipment but also in proper catching instruction to maximize your effectiveness behind the plate.
At HomeRunHitterz, we're committed to helping catchers find the perfect gear for their needs and budget. Have questions about specific catching equipment? Drop a comment below or contact our team directly for personalized recommendations!
Disclaimer: HomeRunHitterz may receive a small commission when you purchase products through our links, but this never influences our recommendations. We only suggest equipment we believe in.
Add comment
Comments